Blog

Getting Dirty

9 min readBy Entegro Health

What if getting “dirty” is actually good for your health?

You've probably heard the saying "A little dirt don't hurt!" Perhaps you’ve heard that running around outside barefoot can actually benefit your immune system, or that getting exposed to pet dander and farm animals can help prevent allergies.1 Thoughts like these became popularized through a theory called the hygiene hypothesis. But is there any scientific truth behind these “go outside and get dirty” concepts?2

Four children laughing while playing in mud in a grassy field outdoors

The Hygiene Hypothesis

The origin of the hygiene hypothesis dates back to 1989 with epidemiologist David P. Strachan. He proposed that the lower occurrence of infections during early childhood in the 20th century possibly explains the rise in allergic diseases like hay fever and eczema.34 Furthermore, this theory claims that exposure to certain microbial factors, including pathogens, can actually help develop the immune system and prevent future disease.

In this modern day, developed countries like the United States have increased sanitation, better water supply, and children with overall fewer infections. Even so, allergies and immune disorders continue to increase significantly. In fact, over the 20th century, rates of disorders such as Crohn’s disease, type 1 diabetes, and asthma rose steeply.5 In Finland, for example, childhood type 1 diabetes roughly doubled between 1980 and 2005.6 From these statistics alone, it’s no wonder theories like the hygiene hypothesis exist in an attempt to explain the surge of these disorders.

Learning from the Amish

A mother and young child crouched beside a brown calf on a family farm

To better understand the hygiene hypothesis, let’s look at a real-life example. One way to try and understand why people are suffering from more allergies in the United States is by finding a population that has fewer allergies in the same country. What population is this? The Amish living in Indiana! Here, the Amish practice farming the way their ancestors did hundreds of years ago. For instance, they use horses and buggies to get around, as well as for pulling plows on the farms. Even more, they drink raw unpasteurized milk.

Studies have tried to confirm whether or not Amish children actually have fewer allergies than children living in a more suburban environment. In one study, over 100 Amish children received skin tests. Then, the Amish results were compared to Swiss farm and non-farm children, who were tested with a different method. In the study’s results, about 44% of Swiss non-farm children tested positive (indicating allergies) while only 7% of Amish children had a positive skin test.7

Generally, researchers believe it is early life exposures that protect the Amish from the development of allergies. Pregnant mothers work in the barn on a daily basis. Likewise, the children spend time in the barn at an early age and are around large farm animals daily. It is all these factors coming together that make some researchers believe the Amish have fewer allergies and asthma cases. Nonetheless, research is still expanding to look at even more detailed aspects of Amish farm life and how it leads to protection from allergies.

A note on raw milk

Raw milk is not the explanation: a 2016 study found that Amish and Hutterite families both drink it, yet only the Amish children had very low rates of asthma.8 Health agencies advise against giving raw milk to children.910

Research on Playing in a Natural Soil Environment

Close view of a woodland forest floor with soil, pine needles, twigs and green seedlings

A study in Finland looked to see if switching a child’s playground substrate from gravel to a natural forest floor could improve their immune systems through exposure to a greater variety of skin and gut bacteria. 75 children between three and five years old at 10 daycare centers in Finland were studied for one month. In four of the daycare centers, gravel playgrounds were made into a field of forest floor, soil, and grasses. The other six daycare centers were control groups with three centers having the forest floor setting already and three centers that kept the gravel.11

After one month, researchers collected blood, skin, and fecal samples from all the children. The scientists found a dramatic difference in the microbiota of the children that went from a gravel playground to a natural soil playground. In only one month, their microbiota shifted to similar microbiomes of the children that already played in a natural setting. Moreover, a change was found in the children’s immune systems. The same children that went from gravel to natural playground substrates developed a higher ratio of anti-inflammatory proteins in their blood. This suggests a shift toward immune regulation, though a one-month study cannot show whether it affects allergies or asthma later on.1213

Critics of the Hygiene Hypothesis

As with most scientific hypotheses, there are always critics (and that’s a good thing!). The hygiene hypothesis generates plenty of controversies, specifically with the use of the term ‘hygiene.’ Critics believe the label is overly simplistic. They argue that it may discourage people from necessary hygienic practices like disinfecting after handling raw meat or being cautious of germs when having the flu or other contagious illnesses. Therefore, some scientists believe that the hygiene hypothesis should include advocating for “targeted hygiene” to make sure people don’t take the “getting dirty” concept too far.14

Getting dirty safely

Cover the sandbox and clean up after pets, keep tetanus shots up to date, and wash hands before eating and after handling animals or gardening.1516

Other names for improving this theory include the biodiversity hypothesis and the disappearing microbiota hypothesis. The biodiversity hypothesis proposes that interacting with natural environments enriches the human microbiome and helps balance the immune system. In turn, people develop greater protection from allergies and inflammatory diseases.17 The disappearing microbiota hypothesis states that the beneficial microbes we coevolved with are now going away. Whether this is due to excessive antibiotic use and being overly sterile or from a lack of getting dirty in nature, more research is needed.18

According to some scientists, more research is needed to better understand whether children playing in the soil are healthier in the long run. Claiming that playing in nature leads to lower diseases is a very complex extrapolation to make. As a result, these studies (including the ones shared earlier) need 10 to 30-year follow-ups to properly challenge their conclusions for proper long-term results.

Playing Outside Benefits Our Health!

Regardless of the microbial scientific debate, other research is emerging showing that playing outside can provide a huge amount of health benefits for children and people of all ages. Children who play outside are shown to have a lower body mass index (BMI) and better cognitive and social development. Interestingly, research also shows that playing outside regularly contributes to better long-distance vision than children who are mostly indoors.19 Furthermore, outdoor light also provides benefits to vision as well as providing a natural source of Vitamin D.

We know that there are many links between the microorganisms that live within us and our health. And these connections continue to emerge through scientific research in real-time! Indeed, the science is still unfolding. Even so, it is clear that our surroundings can impact the diversity of our microbiome and the robustness of our immune system.20

Get More Good Bacteria Daily with Probiotics!

Are you and your family exposed to enough beneficial bacteria every day? You can be sure you and your loved ones get a daily dose of good bacteria with Flourish living probiotics by Entegro Health.

A young child holding a bottle of Entegro Health Flourish Junior living probiotic

Ready to try a living probiotic?

Eleven living strains. One daily shot. For the whole family.

Shop Flourish Original · Shop Flourish Junior · When to take it

About this article

Written by: Kelsy Armstrong, Entegro Health | Originally published: September 2022

Important information

The content in this post is not intended to be professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health providers with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.

These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Sources

  1. Jhun, I., Phipatanakul, W. “Early Exposure to Dogs and Farm Animals Reduces Risk of Childhood Asthma.” Evid Based Med, vol. 21, no. 2, Apr. 2016, p. 80. Source
  2. Castaneda, R., & Schroeder, M. (2019). Could getting dirty and being exposed to germs boost your health? US News & World Report, Wellness — a general-audience overview of the debate. Source
  3. Strachan, D. P. (1989). Hay fever, hygiene, and household size. BMJ, 299(6710), 1259–1260. Source
  4. Strachan, D. “Family Size, Infection and Atopy: The First Decade of the ‘Hygiene Hypothesis.’” Thorax, vol. 55, Aug. 2000. Source
  5. Bach, J.-F. (2002). The effect of infections on susceptibility to autoimmune and allergic diseases. New England Journal of Medicine, 347(12), 911–920. Source
  6. Harjutsalo, V., Sjöberg, L., & Tuomilehto, J. (2008). Time trends in the incidence of type 1 diabetes in Finnish children: a cohort study. The Lancet, 371(9626), 1777–1782. Source
  7. Holbreich, M., Genuneit, J., Weber, J., Braun-Fahrländer, C., Waser, M., & von Mutius, E. (2012). Amish children living in northern Indiana have a very low prevalence of allergic sensitization. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 129(6), 1671–1673 — 138 Amish children skin-prick tested; comparison groups were Swiss farm and non-farm children tested by serum IgE. Source
  8. Stein, M. M., Hrusch, C. L., Gozdz, J., et al. (2016). Innate immunity and asthma risk in Amish and Hutterite farm children. New England Journal of Medicine, 375(5), 411–421 — 30 Amish and 30 Hutterite children; endotoxin 4,399 vs 648 EU/m²; murine model with MyD88/Trif-deficient mice. Source
  9. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Raw Milk. Source
  10. U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Raw Milk Misconceptions and the Danger of Raw Milk Consumption. Source
  11. Roslund, M. I., Puhakka, R., Grönroos, M., et al. (2020). Biodiversity intervention enhances immune regulation and health-associated commensal microbiota among daycare children. Science Advances, 6(42), eaba2578 — 75 children aged 3–5, ten daycare centers, 28-day intervention. Source
  12. Hale, T. (2020). Playing in a natural environment boosts a kid's immune system within a month. IFLScience — popular coverage of the Roslund trial. Source
  13. Sweet, J. (2020). How your kid's microbiome can be affected when they play outside. Healthline — popular coverage of the same trial. Source
  14. Bloomfield, S. F., Rook, G. A., Scott, E. A., Shanahan, F., Stanwell-Smith, R., & Turner, P. (2016). Time to abandon the hygiene hypothesis: new perspectives on allergic disease, the human microbiome, infectious disease prevention and the role of targeted hygiene. Perspectives in Public Health, 136(4), 213–224. Source
  15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Toxocariasis. Source
  16. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. About Tetanus. Source
  17. Haahtela, T. “A Biodiversity Hypothesis.” Allergy. 2019; 74: 1445–1456. Source
  18. Blaser, M. J., & Falkow, S. (2009). What are the consequences of the disappearing human microbiota? Nature Reviews Microbiology, 7(12), 887–894. Source
  19. He, M., Xiang, F., Zeng, Y., et al. (2015). Effect of time spent outdoors at school on the development of myopia among children in China: a randomized clinical trial. JAMA, 314(11), 1142–1148 — 1,903 children, twelve schools, three years. Source
  20. Sobko, T., et al. “Impact of Outdoor Nature-Related Activities on Gut Microbiota, Fecal Serotonin, and Perceived Stress in Preschool Children: The Play and Grow Randomized Controlled Trial.” Sci Rep, vol. 10, 2020. Source

Keep reading

All articles
  • Simple Roasted Asparagus

    2 min read

    A three-ingredient side dish that feeds the beneficial bacteria in your gut. Asparagus is high in the prebiotic inulin, and roasting it with avocado oil and Everything But…

  • Back-to-School Starts in the Gut

    6 min read

    The back-to-school reset comes down to three things a household can genuinely change: what goes in the lunchbox, when the lights go off, and how gently the first…